Web Design

Google Analytics Alternatives for a Small Business Website: Prices, Free Plans and What You Give Up

Most lists of Google Analytics alternatives are written by the tools on them, for product teams with apps and funnels. A small business site has a simpler question: how many people came, from where, and did they get in touch? This guide compares seven options on that job, with every price and claim taken from the makers' own pages on 14 November 2026, and says honestly what you lose when you leave Google's tool.

Google Analytics Alternatives for a Small Business Website: Prices, Free Plans and What You Give Up

Key takeaways

  • You may not need to pay at all. Cloudflare Web Analytics and Microsoft Clarity are free, Umami Cloud has a free tier up to 100,000 events a month, and Simple Analytics has a free plan for hobby sites.
  • The paid privacy tools start between $9 and $20 a month. Plausible's Starter plan is $9 a month for up to 10,000 pageviews; Fathom is $15 for up to 100,000; Simple Analytics is $20 for 100,000.
  • Several makers say no cookie banner is needed for their tool. Plausible, Fathom, Simple Analytics and Umami all say they work without cookies. That is their claim, not legal advice, and your other scripts still count.
  • Google Analytics 4 uses cookies. Google's own help page lists the _ga cookie, kept for two years by default, to tell users apart.
  • Leaving GA4 has a cost. Google Analytics links with Search Console and Google Ads. If you run Google Ads, keep GA4 or plan the switch carefully.
  • Watch behaviour, not just numbers. Microsoft Clarity adds free session recordings and heatmaps, and can run next to any of the others.

The short answer

If you only want to know how many people visit and where they come from, start with a free tool: Cloudflare Web Analytics, or Umami Cloud's free tier. If you want a cleaner dashboard with goals, and makers who say you can drop the cookie banner, pay for Plausible (from $9 a month) or Fathom (from $15). If you want to watch how people use your pages, add Microsoft Clarity, which is free. If you run Google Ads or rely on Google's reports, keep Google Analytics 4. Many small sites end up with two tools: one for numbers, one for behaviour.

Who is writing, and a disclosure: Amariq builds websites and sets up analytics as part of each launch. Our own site, amariq.com, runs Google Analytics 4. We have no affiliate deals with any tool below and have not run a side-by-side test of them. Every price and claim below was read on the tool makers' sites on 14 November 2026.

What ranks for this search, and what it leaves out

We searched Google (US, English) on 14 November 2026. Google's AI summary named Plausible, Fathom, Simple Analytics, Matomo, Umami, Celebrus and Clicky. The ranking pages were mostly written by vendors: Amplitude's list of nine starts with Amplitude, Mixpanel's list of eight starts with Mixpanel, and Celebrus's list starts with Celebrus. A personal blog (14 February 2026) recommends Rybbit and notes that it may contain affiliate links. InstaPods compared six tools (23 July 2026), and Axeptio covered six platforms (25 September 2026).

Those lists serve product teams that need funnels, retention and user profiles. None sets the prices side by side at the traffic level of a small business site, none points out the free analytics many sites already have, and the vendor lists understandably put their own product first.

The seven options compared

ToolEntry price (maker's page, 14 Nov 2026)Free optionCookies, per the makerGood for
Plausible$9 a month, up to 10,000 pageviews, one site (Starter)30-day free trial, no card"No cookies"; says no banner is neededA clear dashboard with goals
Fathom$15 a month, up to 100,000 pageviews, 50 sites7-day free trial, card required"Analytics without the cookies"Several small sites on one plan
Simple Analytics$20 a month, 100,000 pageviews, 1 userFree plan: 5 websites, 1 month of history, badge required"No cookies, no consent banners"A one-page dashboard
Umami Cloud$20 a month for 1 million events (Pro)Hobby: $0, up to 100,000 events, 1 website, 6 months of data"No cookies, no consent banner"Free start, open source
Matomo Cloud22 EUR a month excluding tax, 50,000 hits (Business)Free trial; self-hosted On-Premise version offeredNot checkedA full Google-style suite you control
Cloudflare Web AnalyticsFreeFreeNo cookies or localStorage, no fingerprintingBasic numbers at no cost
Microsoft ClarityFree"Free forever", no traffic limitsNot checkedSession recordings and heatmaps
Google Analytics 4 (for comparison)FreeFreeUses _ga cookies, two years by defaultGoogle Ads and Search Console reports

Notes on the table. Plausible's higher plans at the same 10,000 pageviews are Growth at $14 (up to 3 sites) and Business at $19 (up to 10 sites, with funnels); its price rises with traffic. Fathom's next steps are $25 for 200,000 pageviews and $45 for 500,000. Simple Analytics charges $20 a month for each extra user. Umami's Pro plan adds up to 20 websites and two years of data, and charges $0.00003 for each event over a million. Matomo showed us its price in euros; prices can show in a different currency depending on where you are, so check the page from your own country before you budget.

What you give up when you leave Google Analytics

Search Console reports inside Analytics. Google's help page describes two reports you get by linking the tools: Google Organic Search Queries and Google Organic Search Traffic. They show which searches lead to clicks and how those visitors behave on your landing pages. Search Console itself stays free and works without Google Analytics, so you keep the search data; you lose the combined view.

Google Ads measurement. Google's cookie page says that when Analytics is linked to a Google Ads account, its tags set extra cookies so Ads can measure interactions. If paid search is a large part of how you win work, keep GA4, or have someone set up Ads conversion tracking separately before you remove it.

Familiarity. Freelancers, agencies and many marketing tools expect GA4. That is not a reason to keep it, but it is a cost to plan for.

What you gain is simpler reports, and with the cookie-free tools, fewer scripts that need consent. Plausible says its script is 54 times smaller than Google Analytics; that is the maker's own comparison. For how scripts affect speed in general, see our Core Web Vitals guide.

Pick by the job you need done

Your situationStart with
Brochure site, you only want visits and sourcesCloudflare Web Analytics (free) or Umami Cloud Hobby (free)
You want goals, such as form sends, on a clean dashboardPlausible or Fathom
You run several small sitesFathom (50 sites on its entry plan) or Umami Pro (up to 20)
You want to see where people get stuckMicrosoft Clarity, alongside any of the above
You need a full suite and want to own the dataMatomo, in its cloud or on your own server
You run Google AdsKeep Google Analytics 4

A form send is the number most small businesses care about. Whatever you pick, set it up as a goal or event on day one, ideally on a thank-you page that only loads after a real submission, so each enquiry counts once.

This is not legal advice. Plausible, Fathom, Simple Analytics and Umami each say their tool does not use cookies, and several say you can drop the consent banner. Whether you need a banner depends on everything your site loads, not only analytics: embedded videos, chat widgets, ad pixels and fonts can all set cookies or send data. Our guide to GDPR cookie consent explains the rules and how to test a banner, and our privacy policy guide covers what to tell visitors about the tools you use.

How to switch without losing data

  1. Run the new tool next to GA4 for at least a month. Fathom's pricing page suggests exactly this during its trial. Numbers will not match exactly, because tools count differently.
  2. Set up your goals in the new tool first: form sends, calls, bookings.
  3. Keep the old data. Plausible lists a Google Analytics import among its Starter features. For other tools, export the GA4 reports you care about before you remove the tag.
  4. Update your privacy policy to name the new tool.
  5. Remove the GA4 tag only when you trust the new numbers, and only if you do not rely on it for Google Ads.

If your site is built on Webflow, WordPress, Shopify or another platform, adding any of these tools is a script in the site's head or a plugin. The website audit checklist includes checking that analytics records what you think it does.

How Amariq can help

When we build a site, we set up analytics around the actions that matter to your business, such as form sends, calls and bookings, and we put the accounts in your name so the data stays yours. If you want to move off Google Analytics, we can set up the new tool, run both side by side and tell you what changes in your reports before anything is removed. We work on Webflow, Framer, WordPress, Shopify, Wix, Squarespace and hand-coded sites. Work is quoted from the scope rather than by the hour, paid 40% to begin, 30% when the design is approved and 30% before launch, and the design, copy and code are yours after the final payment. See our website optimization service or web design service.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best free alternative to Google Analytics?

For basic visit numbers, Cloudflare Web Analytics is free and, per Cloudflare, uses no cookies or localStorage. Umami Cloud's free Hobby plan covers one website and up to 100,000 events a month. For recordings and heatmaps, Microsoft Clarity is free.

Is Google Analytics still free?

Yes. Google's Analytics page says it gives you the tools free of charge. It uses first-party cookies, which matters for consent.

How much does Plausible Analytics cost?

On 14 November 2026, Plausible's Starter plan was $9 a month for up to 10,000 monthly pageviews and one site, with Growth at $14 and Business at $19 at the same traffic. It offers a 30-day free trial without a card, and two months free on yearly billing.

Possibly. Several makers say their tool needs no banner, but the answer depends on every other script and embed on your site. Check everything the site loads, and treat this as a question for your own legal adviser.

Can I use Microsoft Clarity with another analytics tool?

Yes. Clarity focuses on session recordings and heatmaps, so it is often used next to a tool that counts visits and sources.

Will I lose my Search Console data if I leave Google Analytics?

No. Search Console is a separate free tool and keeps working. You lose the two Search Console reports that appear inside Google Analytics when the tools are linked.

Is Matomo free?

Matomo offers a self-hosted On-Premise version as well as Matomo Cloud. On 14 November 2026, Matomo Cloud's Business plan was shown to us at 22 EUR a month excluding tax for 50,000 hits. Self-hosting needs your own server and someone to maintain it.

Which analytics tool is best for a small business website?

The one that answers your questions with the least effort. For most small sites, that means visits, sources and form sends: a free tool or Plausible or Fathom covers it. Keep Google Analytics if you run Google Ads.

Rahat Khondokar, founder of Amariq

Rahat Khondokar

Founder & CEO, Amariq

Rahat designs and builds websites for marketing teams and ecommerce brands, and writes here about the structure, copy and conversion work behind them. More about Amariq. Find him on YouTube, Dribbble and LinkedIn.

Keep reading

Related articles.

All articles

How Long Does DNS Propagation Really Take? What Decides the Wait, and a Launch-Day Plan That Keeps It Short
Web Design·8 November 2026

How Long Does DNS Propagation Really Take?

DNS propagation is cache expiry, set by TTL, not a fixed 48 hours. A launch-day plan to lower TTL, switch safely and check. Sources checked 8 Nov 2026.

How to Transfer a Domain Name Without Downtime: The Order of Steps, the Locks and Codes, and the Email Check
Web Design·8 November 2026

How to Transfer a Domain Name Without Downtime

A step order for moving a domain to a new registrar without breaking your site or email, from ICANN's policy and Cloudflare's guides. Checked 8 Nov 2026.